Listing Tools (detailViewNewGen)

Video Available Upon Request.

This is a rare opportunity to live off Central Park in a spacious 3,840 sq. ft triplex apartment and have your two free market rental apartments pay all of the real estate taxes, heat, electricity, insurance, super-everything!-and still have money left over to pay towards the mortgage. An historic townhouse, 58 West 85th Street is a beautifully restored and renovated 3-unit brownstone on one of the prettiest tree-lined townhouse blocks on the Upper West Side with approximately 5,785 square feet total interior space on 5 floors. Your triplex has one of the UWS's best gardens, 18' x 26' south facing and no intruding extensions. This house offers future opportunity to expand or adjust the living space to your evolving needs, convert to a single family or make a 3 unit condominium. And you bought it for half of what condos are selling for per sq ft on the UWS.

Here are the economics: The two tenants are paying a combined $8,335 monthly which is $100,020 annually. The tenants pay their own electric. The owner pays the building's real estate taxes of $58,700 annually (this is a Class 1 house so increase in RET are limited to 6%/year) and the operating expenses (heat, electric, insurance, water, service contracts and maintenance) all of which comes to under $20,000 annually. That leaves an annual profit to the owner of about $21,000. No common charges, no real estate taxes. And a far better value than paying over $2,000 per square foot for a condo (call me and I will show you the math!)

Layout:

Garden
This floor is accessed through a gated under-stoop entrance and has a front bedroom with full bath, a laundry room and a large media/family room/office. There is a wet bar and the first of three beautifully detailed wood burning fireplaces. The sun washed South facing garden is 18 x 26, has evening lighting which accents the elaborate plantings, dining seating for 6 and a convenient barbecue. Below the garden floor is a high ceiling cellar with approximately 1,000 sq ft of storage.

Parlor
Guests and tenants enter through the proper original box stoop with its restored stone details. The building vestibule includes 3" thick oak doors with OG glass, a large pier mirror and the original oak wainscoting and staircase. The Owner's triplex is entered here through a generous foyer. The front facing (in the old European style) eat in kitchen is 10 x 18, comfortable and bright with two nearly full floor to ceiling arched windows. Top of the line appliances are along both walls. The 16 x 25 formal living and dining spaces are conveniently at the rear and seamlessly blend classic detail and modern style. The highlight is the 11' high wall of windows which spans the entire rear of this floor, overlooking the magnificent gardens behind this home. The second wood burning fire place and a spectacular custom interior staircase add sophisticated character. There is also a small terrace overlooking the garden. Powder room is centrally located on this level.

Third Floor
Three bedrooms on this floor including large master suite with 3 closets, 3 windows over serene treetop views. Two full bathrooms and additional neatly configured storage are on this floor.

Fourth Floor Apartment
Free market, floor thru one bedroom apartment with large terrace. Tenant in place through August 2020 paying market rent.

Fifth Floor Apartment
Free market, floor thru two bedroom apartment. Tenant in place through September 2021 paying market rent.

Property Details of 58 W 85th Street, Unit NA

Property Details

Interior Features

Other Details

Map Location

Listed by Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC / Wolf Jakubowski

Listing Sold by Allendale

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved. RLS Data display by Christie's International Real Estate Group.

Hi there! How can we help you?

Contact us using the form below or give us a call.

Send Us A Message:

I agree to receive marketing and customer service calls and text messages from Christie's International Real Estate Group. To opt out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg/data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Privacy Policy.

Do not fill in this field:

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.